
The BBC website today featured a great story on the use of smart phones in pub quizzes. The article is really insightful and if you read it from different perspectives it makes you think about all sorts of new ideas and applications for technology. I thought it was work mentioning on my blog.
Here is an excerpt:
Text-messaging Is Destroying the Pub Quiz As We Know It, noted the Super Furry Animals in 2001. Little did they know that the pub quiz of 2011 would start with the host insisting: “OK, iPhones away, please. Yes, very clever – and Androids. All phones away.”
Cheating has always been possible in pub quizzes. But while once the dishonest quizzer had to pop out to phone a friend, or wait for a text message reply, phones with fast internet access have taken cheating possibilities to a new level.
So on the one hand, 24/7 access to information threatens to deal a deadly blow to the tradition of competitively recalling facts over a few pints. On the other, smartphones offer an opportunity to question-setters to come up with more inventive ways of testing drinkers’ knowledge.
Some rounds are safe. The traditional A4 sheet with photos of well-known people can’t be farmed out to the internet. But it’s not feasible to base every round on colour printouts.
Others need to adapt. Playing extracts from pop songs risks competitors searching for the lyrics. Lyric rounds themselves are obviously out, along with naming titles or chart places.
Better to use instrumentals, perhaps – although services like Shazam allow the devious to have a remote server identify a track if their phone can “hear” 10 seconds of it. A truly secure music round might consist of “mash-ups” – two songs played or mixed together, or even of sheet music.
The challenge for quizmasters is to ask for things that computers don’t – or can’t – know. Machines can be better than any human at chess, for example, but are not so hot at cryptic crosswords.
So a smartphone-proof quiz might feature questions which can only be solved by making associations. For example, what connects a single by the Pogues, an Italian island resort and a unit of electrical current? (Answer in the box at the bottom.)
“The more you complicate a question, the more Google-proof it becomes,” says Thomas Eaton, who sets questions for The Weakest Link. “You can set something up and then ask people to make elliptical connections – the kind of thing you get in Round Britain Quiz on Radio 4.” Another examples is the “What links…?” section of Eaton’s weekly quiz in the Guardian.
End the excerpt!!
You can find the fulls tory here